দুর্নীতি নিয়ে দুর্ভাবনা

`yb©xwZ wb‡q `yf©vebv

W.†dviKvb Avjx

cywj‡ki `yb©xwZ wb‡q Avgv‡`i †`‡ki eo eo cwÊZeM© eoB `yf©vebvq c‡o‡Qb| wK K‡i cywj‡ki `yb©xwZ Kgv‡bv hvq G wPš—vq A‡b‡Ki Nyg nvivg n‡q‡Q| Zv‡`i K_v ï‡b Ges †jLv c‡o AvgviI fxgiwZ a‡i‡Q| cywj‡ki fveg~wZ© wKfv‡e †div‡bv hvq G wPš—vq MZ 3/4 w`b iv‡Z Nyg nqwb| wPš—vq wPš—vq hLb kixi-gb K¬vš— ZLb nVvr Ô†gIÕ k‡ã mw¤^Z wd‡i cvB| ew¼gP‡›`ªi weL¨vZ weovjwU Zvi fvemyjf fvlvq ej‡jv, ÔA‡Zv wPš—v K‡iv bv| `yb©xwZ bv _vK‡j †hgb cywj‡ki `iKvi n‡e bv, †Zgwb cywjk bv _vK‡j `yb©xwZI _vK‡e bv| †mUv wK †Zvgiv PvI?Õ Avwg ewj, Ônu¨v, evsjv‡`‡ki me gvbyl `yb©xwZgy³ mgvR Pvq|Õ weovjwU ej‡jv, Ô†`k †_‡K cywjk wefvM Zz‡j `vI| cywjk I `yb©xwZ nvZ aivawi K‡i P‡j| G‡K ev` w`‡q Ii Aw¯—Z¡ _vK‡e bv| †Zvgiv wK PvI?Õ AZtci weovjwU wgwj‡q †M‡jv| weov‡ji ÁvbMf© K_v KwU gv_vi g‡a¨ NyicvK †L‡Z jvM‡jv| Avgvi wK ¶gZv Av‡Q cywjk evwnbx Zz‡j †`evi? miKvi †Zv w`b †K w`b cywj‡ki msL¨v evwo‡qB P‡j‡Q| cywj‡ki msL¨vi m‡½ Zvj wg‡j‡q `yb©xwZI evo‡Q| ZvB †Zv `yb©xwZi kx‡l© cywjk evwnbxi ¯’vb Avgv‡`i †`‡ki gy‡Lv¾¡j K‡i‡Q| hviv `yb©xwZ `~i Ki‡e ZvivB `yb©xwZ‡Z P¨vw¤úqb| Ggb †`kwU Avi †Kv_vI †`‡L‡Qb? 10 wW‡m¤^i mgKv‡j Ô`yb©xwZi kx‡l© cywjkÕ wk‡ivbv‡gi wb‡P wgicyi g‡Wj _vbv cywj‡ki mve-B݇c±i (GmAvB) iwKeyj nvmv‡bi QwewU †mUvB cÖgvY Ki‡Q|

iv‡m‡ji Pzwi n‡jv| cywj‡ki Kv‡Q †M‡jv| c‡KU †_‡K Av‡iv †ewk UvKv †ewi‡q †M‡jv| †mLvb †_‡K wePv‡ii Avkvq †M‡jv wePvivj‡q| †mLvb †_‡K wbt¯^ n‡q †ei n‡q gv_vq nvZ w`‡q wePvivj‡qi gv‡VB e‡m co‡jv| evwo †divi cqmv ch©š— †Pvi, cywjk I Av`vjZ Pz‡l wb‡q‡Q| G `„k¨ G †`‡ki gvby‡li Kv‡Q G‡Zv cwiwPZ †h Zv Avi we¯—vwiZ †jLvi `iKvi c‡o bv| G eQ‡ii UªvÝcv‡iwÝ B›Uvib¨vkbv‡ji wi‡cv‡U©I †mB wPÎB D‡V G‡m‡Q| GK b¤^‡i cywjk, `yBÑ RbcÖkvmb, wZbÑ ivR‰bwZK `j Ges PZz_©Ñ wePvi wefvM|

`yB. G †`‡ki weÁmgvR I b„-weÁvbx‡`i M‡elYvi Rb¨ G GK PgrKvi Z_¨| G e¨vcv‡i Avgvi GKUv Dc‡`k Av‡Q| XvKvi GKwU AÂj †_‡K cywjk cÖZ¨vnvi K‡i GK eQ‡ii Rb¨ ch©‡e¶Y Kiv †h‡Z cv‡i| †m A‡j †Kv‡bv _vbv _vK‡e bv, cywjk _vK‡e bv| Avgvi †hb †Kb g‡b nq, hw` cywj‡ki msL¨vi m‡½ `yb©xwZi m¤úK© abvZ¥K directly proportional nq Zvn‡j cywjknxb mgv‡R `yb©xwZI k~‡b¨ †b‡g Avmvi K_v| G M‡elYvwU Zviv K‡i †`L‡Z cv‡ib| KviY cywj‡ki m‡½ `yb©xwZi m¤úK© ejv hvq wek¦Rbxb| DbœZ we‡k¦i K_v ejv n‡q‡QÑ †mLv‡b bvwK cywjk `yb©xwZgy³| K_vwU m¤ú‡K© Avgvi GKUz m‡›`n Av‡Q| Zvn‡j †Lv` Bsj¨v‡Û mf¨Zvi m~wZKvMvi e‡j cwiwPZ †`k, AvB‡bi euv nvZ (The Left Hand of the Law) bv‡gi wm‡bgv nq wK K‡i? miKvi `yb©xwZ `g‡bi Rb¨ h‡Zv Kov AvBb cÖYqb Ki‡e ev wb‡`©k †`‡e, `yb©xwZ Z‡Zv e„w× cv‡e, cvq| ZLb mvaviY gvby‡li c‡KU †_‡K Av‡iv †ewk cqmv †jvcvU n‡q hvq| wiKkv fvov B`vbxs ga¨we‡Ëi bvMv‡ji evB‡i P‡j †M‡Q| †LuvR wb‡q †`‡LwQ, Zv‡`i `yRvqMvq Rgv w`‡Z nq| GKÑ wiKkvi gvwjK‡K, wØZxqZÑ cywjk‡K| †m cqmvUv Avgv‡`i c‡KU †K‡U wiKkvIqvjv †kva †`q| cywjk KL‡bv Pvq bv †`k †_‡K `yb©xwZ `~i †nvK| Zvn‡j Zv‡`i wec`| msmvi Pj‡e bvÑ evwo evwo n‡e bv BZ¨vw`| Kv‡RB `yb©xwZ _vK‡eB| h‡Zv cywjk evo‡e, `yb©xwZi cwigvY Z‡ZvB evo‡e|

wZb. †hgb eZ©gvb ÔgvwK©wb MYZš¿Õ| †m MYZ‡š¿i Rb¨ Ômš¿vmev‡`iÕ Dcw¯’wZ Acwinvh©| c„w_ex‡Z hw` ÔgvwK©wb MYZš¿‡KÕ wU‡K _vK‡Z nq, Zvn‡j hy³ivóª‡K wewjqb-wUªwjqb Wjvi LiP K‡i mš¿vmev` wRB‡q ivL‡ZB n‡e| 9/11-Gi Av‡Mi w`b ivgm‡dÛ †c›UvM‡bi Kg©KZ©v‡`i m‡½ wgwUs-G 2.3 wUªwjqb Wjv‡ii wnmve cvIqv hv‡”Q bv e‡j wi‡cvU© K‡iwQ‡jb| 2.3 wUªwjqb Wjvi? Avgv‡`i KíbviI evB‡i| whïwLª÷ hw` R‡b¥i ci cÖwZw`b 20 nvRvi Wjvi K‡i LiP Ki‡Zb, Zvn‡j bvwK Av‡Rv 2.3 wUªwjqb Wjvi LiP n‡Zv bv| G‡Zv Wjvi †Kv_vq †M‡jv?

hviv me mgq Avgv‡`i Ô¯^”QZvÕ eRvq ivLvi Dc‡`k w`‡q hv‡”Qb, Zv‡`i †c›UvMb Znwe‡ji ¯^”QZv _vK‡e bv GUv wK fvev hvq? G wb‡q Ríbv-Kíbvi Aš— †bB| `ygy©L e¨w³iv Am¤¢e K_v e‡jb| UzBb UvIqv‡ii g~j¨ `ywU †c­‡bi g~j¨, `kRb AvZ¥NvZx Ômš¿vmxÕi Rxe‡bi g~j¨ Ges Zv‡`i cwiev‡ii †PŠÏ cyi“‡li e¨e¯’v Ki‡Z bvwK †m Wjvi LiP Ki‡Z n‡q‡Q| G wb‡q †Zgb †Kv‡bv ˆn‰P nqwb| A_P G‡Zv eo Znwej ZQi“‡ci Kvwnbx BwZnv‡m Avi KL‡bv N‡Uwb| ZvB ejwQjvgÑ ÔgvwK©wb MYZš¿Õ Avi Ômš¿vmev`Õ ci¯úi ci¯ú‡ii cwic~iK| †hgb cywjk I `yb©xwZ ci¯ú‡ii cwic~iK| hy³ivóª Rv‡b †mŠw` Avie †`‡k †`‡k mš¿vm Pvjvb Kivi †K›`ª| A_P †mŠw` Avie hy³iv‡óªi NwbôZg wgÎ| wewjqb Wjvi mvnvh¨Ñ A¯¿ wewµ K‡i †mŠw` Avi‡ei gva¨‡g hy³ivóª c„w_ex‡Z mš¿vm wRB‡q ivL‡Q|

Pvi. 2001 mv‡j 9/11-Gi ci hy³ivóª hLb Ômš¿v‡mi wei“‡×Õ hy× †NvlYv Ki‡jv, ZLb g½jMÖ‡ni mvsevw`K w`‡knviv n‡q c„w_ex †Q‡o g½jMÖ‡n wd‡i wM‡qwQj| †m †`L‡jv c„w_exi me‡P‡q eo mš¿vmx hviv †c›UvMb mv`v fe‡b evm K‡i ZvivB mš¿v‡mi wei“‡× hy× †NvlYv K‡i‡Q| m¤cÖwZ 2010 mv‡j Zvi B‡”Q n‡jv Avi GKevi c„w_ex‡Z Avm‡e GLbKvi cwiw¯’wZ †`Levi Rb¨| c„w_exi gvwjK mv`v feb| mv`v fe‡b †m wfmvi Rb¨ `iLv¯— Ki‡jv| Zv‡K ejv n‡jv †m †Kv‡bviKg wi‡cvU© Ki‡Z cvi‡e bvÑ Qwe Zzj‡Z cvi‡e bv| †mB k‡Z© †m c„w_ex‡Z G‡jv| mviv c„w_ex Ny‡i †eov‡jv| Zv‡K Zbœ Zbœ K‡i †Kv‡bv B‡jKUªwbK wWfvBm cvIqv †M‡jv bv| wKš‘ Zvi bZzb e¨e¯’vi K_v mv`v feb Rvb‡Z cvi‡jv bv| g½jMÖ‡n wd‡i c„w_ex m¤ú‡K© wmwiR wjL‡jv| †m wjL‡jvÑ cÖZ¨¶ Jcwb‡ekev` gy³ c„w_ex‡Z AvR mvgªvR¨ev`-we‡ivax †Kvb Av‡›`vjb †bB| hy³ivóª 132wU †`‡k 702wU †mbv K¨v‡¤ú jvL jvL ˆmb¨ †i‡L †mBme †`‡ki gvby‡li MYZš¿ †K‡o wb‡q‡Q| cÖwZwU †`‡ki gvby‡li †fZ‡ii ˆelg¨ I ˆewiZv¸‡jv D‡¯‹ w`‡q †`‡ki gvbyl‡K wef³ K‡i G‡K w`‡q I‡K, I‡K w`‡q G‡K nZ¨v Ki‡Q| Avi gv‡Sg‡a¨ RvnvR fwZ© e¨vjUev‡· ÔMYZš¿Õ fwZ© K‡i †`‡k †`‡k wbe©vP‡b ÔMYZš¿Õ cÖwZôv Ki‡Q| mvZ wKw¯—i wi‡cv‡U©i †k‡l GB e‡j †kl K‡i †h eZ©gv‡b †mLv‡b h‡Zv nvbvnvwb, hy×weMÖn, gvbevwaKvi j•N‡bi NUbv NU‡Q Zvi †cQ‡b cÖZ¨¶ I c‡iv¶fv‡e gvwK©b hy³iv‡óªi f~wgKv cÖavb|

cuvP. †PvLUv Avevi GKUz †j‡M‡Q| Avevi ÔwgIÕ| weovjwU G‡m ej‡jv, cÖ‡dmi mv‡ne, ÒjÛ‡bi wm‡bgv ÔAvB‡bi euv nvZÕ-Gi KvwnbxUv wK GKUz †kvbv‡bv hvq bv| 1960 mv‡ji wm‡bgv| KRb †`‡L‡Qb? Zv‡`i wK †m Kvwnbxi K_v g‡b Av‡Q?Ó e‡jB †m wgwj‡q †M‡jv| †R‡M †`wL †m †bB| Zvn‡j ÔThe Left Hand of the LawÕ wm‡bgvwUi Kvwnbx ms‡¶‡c eY©bv Kwi| AvR‡Ki cywjk m¤ú‡K© †h mZ¨wU cvVK †R‡b‡Qb, †`L‡Qb, Zvi m‡½ †m Qwei K‡Zv wgj| KvwnbxUv GgbÑ cywj‡ki me‡P‡q eo Kg©KZ©vi c‡KU †_‡K gvwbe¨vM nvwi‡q †M‡Q| †Kv‡bv c‡KUgvi Ab¨vqwU K‡i‡Q| m‡½ jÛ‡bi cywjk wefvM Kg©e¨¯— n‡q DV‡jv| Ôm¨v‡ii gvwbe¨vM †hb †ei Ki‡ZB n‡e|Õ †h AÂj †_‡K e¨vMwU nvwi‡q‡Q e‡j m‡›`n nq, †mB A‡j c‡KUgvi‡`i m`©vi‡K †W‡K cywj‡ki wbæc`¯’ GKRb Kg©KZ©v ej‡jv, Ô†h K‡iB †nvK GKw`‡bi g‡a¨ m¨v‡ii e¨vMwU G‡b w`‡Z n‡e|Õ m`©vi h_vixwZ Zvi A‡j me c‡KUgvi‡K †W‡K wRÁvmvev` Ki‡jv| †KD wb‡q‡Q e‡j ¯^xKvi Ki‡jv bv| ZLb m`©vi cywjk‡K Rvbv‡jv †h, Zvi Gwiqvi †Kv‡bv c‡KUgvi m¨v‡ii c‡KU gv‡iwb| Ab¨ †Kv‡bv A‡ji c‡KUgv‡ii KvR| ZLb mviv jÛ‡bi wewfbœ Gwiqvi m`©vi‡`i †W‡K Av‡`k †`qv n‡jv, AgyL Zvwi‡Li g‡a¨ e¨vMwU bv cvIqv †M‡j Lei Av‡Q| e¨vMwU cvIqv †M‡jv bv| ZLb GjvKvi m`©vi‡K cywjk †MÖßvi K‡i| m‡½ jÛ‡bi iv¯—vq iv¯—vq c‡KUgviiv wgwQj †ei K‡i Ges Zv‡`i †bZvi gyw³ `vwe K‡i| Av‡›`vjb Pj‡Z jvM‡jv| c‡KUgviiv fq †`Lv‡jv †h, Zv‡`i †bZv‡K gyw³ bv w`‡j Zviv Zv‡`i e¨emv A_©vr c‡KUgvi eÜ K‡i †`‡e| wbw`©ó Zvwi‡Li ci Zviv mwZ¨ mwZ¨B c‡KUgviv eÜ K‡i w`‡jv| GKw`b hvqÑ `yBw`b hvq| c‡KUgvi‡`i ZrciZv †_‡K jÛbevmx gyw³ cvq| wKš‘ h‡Zv w`b †h‡Z _vK‡jv cywjk Z‡ZvB A‰ah© n‡q DV‡jv| Zv‡`i e¨emv cybivq ïi“i Rb¨ cywj‡ki Zid †_‡K me iK‡gi e¨w³MZ cÖ‡Póv e¨_© nevi ci, GKw`b cywj‡ki EaŸ©Zb Kg©KZ©v‡`i m‡½ c‡KUgvi mwgwZi GK i“×Øvi ˆeV‡K w¯’i nq †h, Zviv Avevi c‡KUgvi ïi“ Ki‡e Ges cywjkI Zv‡`i †bZv‡K †Q‡o †`‡e| Gfv‡eB wgUgvU n‡jv| †bZv gyw³ †c‡jv| c‡KUgviiv cybivq c‡KU KvUv ïi“ Ki‡jv| 

†jLK: M‡elK I mv‡eK Aa¨¶